
Jump to:
Snapshots with Imam Tom Facchine
Why ‘Changing It From Within’ Might Change You Instead | Snapshots with Imam Tom Facchine
Published: November 18, 2026 • Jumada al-Thani 8, 1448
You tell yourself you’ll take the job, climb the ladder, and change things once you get there. But will you actually change the institution? Or will it change you before you even realize? In this Snapshot, Imam Tom Facchine explains why no institution is neutral, and how to walk in with your eyes open.
This episode covers:
— Why “changing it from within” rarely happens
— The difference between benefiting from an institution and being disciplined by it
— The questions to ask of any place
This transcript was auto-generated using AI and may contain misspellings.
00:00How many times have I heard someone say that they're going to enter into a study program, a job, an office, and change the place from within, or they'll be able to climb the ladder of success and then change things once they get there.
00:19Almost every time, once they finally get the position or they reach the position, they don't do anything. That's because they were kidding themselves from the beginning.
00:27Institutions are never just platforms. They are also systems of formation. They transform who you are. You're not the same person that exits it as you were on the way in.
00:37And every institution has assumptions about the human being, morality, authority, success, progress, you name it. They have values, and they're going to discipline you according to those values.
00:47A university doesn't just teach neutral information. It teaches you an entire theory of knowledge, a way of seeing the world. Media and the news don't just report events. They also subtly coach you about how to feel about those events.
00:59Corporations don't just sell you products. They create new desires inside of you and try to get you to identify with those desires.
01:06And NGOs don't just solve problems. They actually define which problems are legitimate and what seems like common sense solutions.
01:14Muslims often enter institutions thinking they can remain untouched, but the stronger the institution, the more invisible the transformation becomes.
01:21The United States public education system is built on the Prussian military schools, historically, and it's this idea of instilling, homogenizing the student population, making them all very much the same, having them respond to discipline and bells and these sorts of things.
01:38It's not necessarily geared or built for education. Now, this doesn't mean that Muslims should withdraw from institutions or not take part in them whatsoever, but it does mean that they should enter with awareness.
01:48Muslim leaders have to know the difference between benefiting from an institution and being disciplined by it. And they should encourage that awareness in the general Muslim masses, and they should also encourage collective strategies.
02:00I can tell you even before Islam, myself and a group of friends moving through undergrad, we decided to take all the same courses every single year, maybe about six of us. And that decision that we made actually changed the tenor and the tone of the classes that we took.
02:14It enabled certain conversations that wouldn't have been possible if it was just one person with their own ideas that, let's say, cut against the grain.
02:23We also need to think about our own institutions, our Muslim institutions, and how they're forming the people who move through them, either towards courage or cowardice, towards sincerity or performance. Are we encouraging service or careerism?
02:36So as a practical question, ask yourself, what kind of person does this place produce after five years? Whether it's an institution that you're in, being formed by, or whether it's one that you're responsible for and that you run.
02:47And you should also ask yourself, is that person, the person that this place produces, the type of person that either I want to become or that I want to produce in others? No institution is neutral.
02:59Are you using the institution or is the institution slowly forming you?



















